Top 8 Best Fertilizers for New Grass | 2020 Reviews (Scotts)

The hardest part every lawn owner experience is growing the very first strands of grass in their lawn. You may be a beginner who decided to make their backyard more beautiful than it is. You may also be an experienced gardener who took on the task of growing brand new seeds in their lawn to make it more beautiful. 

Nevertheless, starting to grow new grass needs a special kind of fertilizer. Purchasing any other fertilizer might damage the soil instead of fertilizing it. However, the number of options at your disposal might overwhelm and blind you into purchasing the wrong fertilizer. Thus, we provided you eight (8) of the best fertilizers we think are perfect for growing new grass. We will also provide our premium recommendation of what fertilizer we think is the best among these options. Finally, we will provide you a series of factors to consider when purchasing your fertilizer. 

Top 8 Best Fertilizers for New Grass Reviewed

  1. Scotts Green Max Lawn Food - Lawn Fertilizer Plus Iron Supplement Builds thick, Green Lawns - Deep Greening in 3 Days - Covers 10,000 sq. ft. – Best Overall
  2. Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Lawn Food, 5 lb. – Best Value
  3. Pennington UltraGreen Starter Lawn Fertilizer, 14 LBS, Covers 5000 sq ft – Editor’s Choice
  4. Scotts Turf Builder Starter Food for New Grass Plus Weed Preventer - 2-in-1 Formula - Fertilizes New Grass and Prevents Weeds like Crabgrass and Dandelions - Covers 5,000 sq. ft.
  5. Simple Lawn Solutions Extreme Grass Growth Lawn Boosters- quality Liquid Spray Concentrated Fertilizers with fulvic & Humic Acid- Any Grass Type (32 oz. w/ Sprayer)
  6. Jonathan Green 11540 Green Up 12-18-8, Seeding & Sodding Lawn Fertilizer, 1,000 sq. ft, Yellow
  7. Milorganite 0605 Garden Care Organic Fertilizer, 5-Pound
  8. Balanced 16-4-8 Nutrient Liquid Fertilizer (32oz Ready to Spray) - Premium Lawn Food, NPK with Added Seaweed Extract, Treats common Deficiencies Safe for All Grass types (Upgraded Sprayer)

#1. Scotts Green Max Lawn Food - Lawn Fertilizer Plus Iron Supplement Builds thick, Green Lawns - Deep Greening in 3 Days - Covers 10,000 sq. ft. – Best Overall

Scotts Green Max Lawn Food - Lawn Fertilizer Plus Iron Supplement Builds thick, Green Lawns - Deep Greening in 3 Days - Covers 10,000 sq. ft.

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications :

  • Expected results in just three days 
  • 2-in-1 formula feeds and supplements 
  • Formulated with iron 
  • Fertilizer will not stain 
  • Applicable in any season 
  • Safe after application 

Many consumers know this company as the most reliable in the industry. Scotts Fertilizers create different fertilizers suitable for almost any kind of soil. They are most known for producing the most effective results in the most efficient way possible. 

This fertilizer is known for making your soil fertile enough to grow your first seed. This fertilizer softens the soil enough to allow the plant to grow without unnecessary obstructions in its way. Your plant will also receive the necessary nutrients to improve its growth through the weeks. Many lawn owners report seeing significant results in just a matter of days! Many fertilizers cannot match the standard set by this fertilizer.

Your plant will receive more doses of Nitrogen designed to grow it efficiently. Your plants will grow from an all-natural fertilizer constantly improving throughout the year. This fertilizer will not stain your soil, which potentially causes ugly marks around your grass field. 

You also do not need to wait for summer to grow your grass. This fertilizer adapts well in almost any season you can subject it to. However, grass growth will slow down in seasons where it isn’t easy to find sufficient sunlight. The fertilizer will nourish your grass through these seasons to prevent it from withering. 

This fertilizer is best for larger lawn areas. This fertilizer can fertilize almost 1,000 sq. ft. of land. If you have a smaller area to occupy, this fertilizer will last you relatively longer. Investing in this fertilizer will stop you from constantly going to your store to purchase new ones. 

More importantly, your household is kept safe after you apply this fertilizer. You will not need to worry about your children getting sick after application. Your children are free to play in your garden after a few minutes of applying this fertilizer. 

ProsCons
Produces deep dark green lawns
Might not work as well in some kinds of soil
Perfect for larger lawn areas
Green lawn in a few weeks
High Nitrogen

#2. Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Lawn Food, 5 lb. – Best Value

Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Lawn Food, 5 lb.

 

Specifications: 

  • Feeds all grass types 
  • Creates a soft green carpet 
  • Feeds up to 7,200 sq. ft. 
  • Creates thick, green lawn 

Miracle-Gro is another fertilizer to consider when growing new grass. This fertilizer can occupy almost 7,200 sq. ft. of land. This fertilizer is known for creating consistent results throughout the years. This consistent performance stems from the company’s extensive research to design the perfect product for your lawn. 

You will not need to think that much about this fertilizer. Directions are given in the package to prevent any mistakes in applying the fertilizer. New lawn owners usually do not contain much knowledge about planting seeds yet. Thus, many lawn owners run to this fertilizer as their first fertilizer. 

You will begin to see significant results in a matter of weeks. This fertilizer will create smooth grass throughout your lawn that many people will envy. You can use this fertilizer in almost any grass type you wish to create. You only need good soil to plant it on, accompanied by sufficient sunlight and water. 

This product is composed mostly of water-soluble lawn food. Most of the product is comprised of purely natural components to prevent any dangerous synthetics from hindering your plant’s growth. 

This fertilizer was specifically designed for new grass. You will receive immediate growth in a matter of weeks without much effort. This product does not work as well in lawns that already contain grass, though. Many customers report the fertilizer burning your grown plants. Thus, you must ensure that you purchase this product when your field is still barren. This fertilizer will soften your soil to allow nutrients to flow to the seed more naturally and effectively. 

Nevertheless, this fertilizer is extremely useful for new gardeners and lawn owners. Its practicality and simplicity astound many new gardeners. You will also see significant results in a matter of weeks. However, we recommend you purchase another fertilizer when your plant grows to the size you want it to be. 

ProsCons
Significant results in a few weeks Do not place it directly on grown plants
Works great on larger areas
Creates lush green fields
Easy to apply
Easy to use

#3. Pennington UltraGreen Starter Lawn Fertilizer, 14 LBS, Covers 5000 sq ft – Editor’s Choice

Pennington UltraGreen Starter Lawn Fertilizer, 14 LBS, Covers 5000 sq ft

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications: 

  • Style: Crabgrass Preventer, Lawn fertilizer, Starter Fertilizer, Weed & Feed 
  • Starter fertilizer for new lawns 
  • Builds strong and thick grass 
  • Faster lawn establishment 
  • Helps all types of grass seed
  • Quick greening 
  • Extended feeding for up to 3 months 
  • Contains 5% Iron 

This product is another fertilizer that helps new gardeners and lawn owners grow their grass to the size they want it to be. These kinds of fertilizers are usually the ones that new gardeners use to fertilize their soil for the many years to come. You will surely experience significant results in just a matter of weeks. 

This fertilizer nourishes your lawn to ensure that your plant receives all the nutrients it needs to grow easily. You will experience your soil becoming more adaptive to the nutrients you provide it as well as the water and sunlight you expose it to. This fertilizer speeds up the growing process, which would usually take a matter of months. 

You can apply this fertilizer to almost any grass type you could think of. It focuses more on reaching these seeds to encourage it to grow quicker than usual. 

More importantly, this fertilizer prevents unwanted weeds from sprouting along with your grass. You can protect your grass from weeds that take the nutrients you intended for your grass. If you perform all the steps indicated in the package correctly, you should successfully grow your favorite grass in a matter of three months. 

However, we recommend that you shift to another fertilizer when your grass grows into maturity. This fertilizer only caters to premature grass seeds. Thus, applying this fertilizer on fertile soil might become too potent for it. The NPK levels are strong enough to soften the grounds upon planting. However, these levels are also dangerous for soils that are already soft and fertile.  

ProsCons
Produces results in a few weeks NPK levels might be too strong for some soils
Works great on any grass
High-performance
Good fertilizer

#4. Scotts Turf Builder Starter Food for New Grass Plus Weed Preventer - 2-in-1 Formula - Fertilizes New Grass and Prevents Weeds like Crabgrass and Dandelions - Covers 5,000 sq. ft.

Scotts Turf Builder Starter Food for New Grass Plus Weed Preventer - 2-in-1 Formula - Fertilizes New Grass and Prevents Weeds like Crabgrass and Dandelions - Covers 5,000 sq. ft.

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications: 

  • 2-in-1 formula feeds new grass and prevents weeds 
  • Prevents crabgrass, dandelions, and other weeds 
  • Improves seeding results 
  • Applicable on and types of grass 
  • Covers over 5,000 sq. ft. 

Scotts Turf is another excellent company where you can purchase almost any kind of fertilizer for your lawn. Their new grass fertilizer is completely different from its competitors in the market. This fertilizer focuses on growing your plant more efficiently without using potentially dangerous synthetic products. 

What draws most of the customers to this product is the fertilizer’s dual-purpose capabilities. This fertilizer ensures that your field is fertile enough to grow grass and other plants. 

This fertilizer also prevents any weeds from forming during the birth of new grass. Gone are the days when you need to worry about the weeds that suck the nutrients out of your grass. This fertilizer lessens the possibility of having to remove weeds. 

You can apply this fertilizer on almost anything you could think of. If you plant this on barren soil, your soil will be fertile enough for many years. If you follow all the directions stated in the package, you will see significant results in a matter of weeks. 

ProsCons
Perfect for new seeds and grass Not suitable for saturated crabgrass
Protects the grass effectively
Perfect for lawn replacement
Covers large areas
Speeds up growth

#5. Simple Lawn Solutions Extreme Grass Growth Lawn Boosters- quality Liquid Spray Concentrated Fertilizers with fulvic & Humic Acid- Any Grass Type (32 oz. w/ Sprayer)

Simple Lawn Solutions Extreme Grass Growth Lawn Boosters- quality Liquid Spray Concentrated Fertilizers with fulvic & Humic Acid- Any Grass Type (32 oz. w/ Sprayer)

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications: 

  • Increases vertical and lateral growth for grass 
  • Advanced humic & fulvic acid formula 
  • Nitrogen and Phosphorus Fertilizer 
  • Perfect for nutrient deficiency 
  • Suitable for all grass types 

This fertilizer focuses on ensuring your grass looks beautiful when it starts to sprout from the ground. Your grass receives the necessary nutrients it needs to grow up to bring more beauty and life into your lawn. You can apply this fertilizer on almost any grass type you can think of. 

You are purchasing a fertilizer containing an advanced humic and fluvic acid formula. These elements contribute to the primary nutrients in a fertilizer. This fertilizer will soften the soil to make it easier for the plant to receive its needed nutrients. 

This product focuses more on Nitrogen and Phosphorus. These two nutrients are responsible for increasing the plant’s growth and ensuring it maintains its beautiful color throughout its growth. You can effectively apply this fertilizer to any soil deficient in these two nutrients. Your plant will receive more of what it lacks and a balanced amount of what it has an abundance of. 

More importantly, this fertilizer is relatively easier to use for beginners. The instructions are clear enough to prevent any distractions and inconvenience in the long run. If you follow these instructions and recommendations correctly, you will see significant growth in a matter of weeks. 

ProsCons
Recommended by many customers
Might not work on some soils
Produces result within weeks
Improves grass growth
Easy to use

#6. Jonathan Green 11540 Green Up 12-18-8, Seeding & Sodding Lawn Fertilizer, 1,000 sq. ft, Yellow

Jonathan Green 11540 Green Up 12-18-8, Seeding & Sodding Lawn Fertilizer, 1,000 sq. ft, Yellow

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications: 

  • Perfect for lawn repairs and sod lawns 
  • High Phosphorus formula 
  • Builds a vigorous root system  
  • Contains iron for deeper greening 

Jonathan Green is a company dedicated to producing all-natural products to help grow healthier plants. This company refuses to include dangerous synthetics on their fertilizer that could kill younger plants.

This fertilizer has a ratio of 12-18-8. In other words, this fertilizer focuses on increasing the chemical composition of Nitrogen and Phosphorus. These two elements are needed to ensure that your plant grows healthily and consistently. These elements ensure that your plant has a deeper root system to attain the necessary nutrients deeper into the soil. 

The domineering elements in this fertilizer also ensure your soil will receive the nutrients it most likely lacks. Fertilizing the soil will also allow the plant to grow without any potential obstructions. In the long run, your grass should have a deep green color in it. A deep green color is a good indicator that your plant receives an adequate amount of nutrients it needs. 

Overall, you are looking at a highly effective, affordable, and all-natural fertilizer. If you apply these instructions correctly, you should see significant results in a couple of weeks. You will usually see this fertilizer among the ranks of the top fertilizers on the market. Its competitive advantage should provide you assurance of the quality you are purchasing. 

ProsCons
Competes well with other more expensive products
Might not be suitable for some soils
Fixes patches in the grass
Fills grass in a few weeks
Highly effective

#7. Milorganite 0605 Garden Care Organic Fertilizer, 5-Pound

Milorganite 0605 Garden Care Organic Fertilizer, 5-Pound

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications: 

  • Garden care organic fertilizer 
  • Contains all 15 growth elements
  • Produces vigorous and healthier grass 
  • Does not dehydrate tender grass plants 
  • Perfect for golf courses 

Milorganite specializes in creating organic fertilizers you can use even after the plants grow to maturity. This fertilizer specializes in caring for your grass by providing its daily dose of nutrients for its color. Many golf courses use this product to continue to keep its grasses rejuvenated after using it during the day. However, many customers purchase this fertilizer for their lawns because they want the deep green color usually present in golf courses. 

The best part about this fertilizer is that it cares for all the plants around its premises. This fertilizer also cares for the other plants you chose to accompany your beautiful grass fields. This fertilizer contains all fifteen growth elements necessary to keep consistent growth throughout usage. 

You do not need to worry about this fertilizer severely affecting your already grown grass. This fertilizer specializes in maintaining the quality of the grass instead of growing or fertilizing the soil. This grass also will not burn your plants like how other low-end fertilizers will. Instead, you will notice significant results in a few weeks. 

This product can cover an area the size of a golf course. You will most likely fill your small lawn many times with this fertilizer before purchasing another one. 

This product was not designed for growth, though. Most of the fertilizer components are not suitable for barren fields that are deficient and infertile. You will need a stronger fertilizer than this. However, if you are planting new grass in a fertilized field, this product is the best for you. 

ProsCons
Significant results in a few weeks Not naturally designed for growing new grass
Perfect for lawn and flowers
Usually slower for some lawn owners
Will not burn your plants
Might not work for some soils
Will impact larger area
Grows thick grass

#8. Balanced 16-4-8 Nutrient Liquid Fertilizer (32oz Ready to Spray) - Premium Lawn Food, NPK with Added Seaweed Extract, Treats common Deficiencies Safe for All Grass types (Upgraded Sprayer)

Balanced 16-4-8 Nutrient Liquid Fertilizer (32oz Ready to Spray) - Premium Lawn Food, NPK with Added Seaweed Extract, Treats common Deficiencies Safe for All Grass types (Upgraded Sprayer)

 

Specifications: 

  • Balanced liquid fertilizer 
  • Suitable for all grass types 
  • Premium blend of fast and slow release of Nitrogen 
  • Promotes green lawns faster 
  • Comes with a hose-end sprayer 
  • 30 days-return guaranteed 

This fertilizer is one of the only balanced liquid fertilizers designed to grow lawns effectively. You can apply this fertilizer on almost any grass type you can think of. This fertilizer will soften your soil to provide your plants with the nutrients it needs. More importantly, this fertilizer produces beautiful results in a matter of weeks. 

This fertilizer features a premium blend of fast and slow release of Nitrogen. This nutrient will allow your plant to grow healthier in a lawn that is deficient in Nitrogen. You will experience your lawns becoming brighter and livelier after a few times of applying this fertilizer. 

You will also receive a hose-end sprayer to disperse the particles around your lawn effectively. This fertilizer can reach a farther distance than other fertilizers. 

The company is so confident about its product that it allows its consumers to return their fertilizer in a span of thirty days if they are not satisfied with its performance. Thus, you can expect that you are receiving premium quality by purchasing this product. 

ProsCons
Treats common nutrient deficiency
Poor packaging decision
Significant results in a few weeks
Enhanced with biostimulants
Suitable for all grass types

Best Fertilizer for New Grass – Our Top Pick 

We decided that the Scotts Green Max Fertilizer is the best fertilizer you can purchase to create beautiful new grass. This fertilizer was specifically designed to effectively grow your lawns into healthier plants that not many fertilizers can. Many customers purchase this product because of how easy it is to apply. 

This fertilizer contains the necessary nutrients that new soils do not possess. Injecting your lawn with this fertilizer will encourage your soil to nourish your plants effectively. These nutrients will lessen the likelihood that weeds will show around your plant when it grows to maturity. 


Best Fertilizer Brand Out There 

Scotts Fertilizers is the best company you can purchase from in the market. Research and dedication were incorporated in their fertilizers to ensure that all customers will reap the benefits of their purchase. Their fertilizers will produce significant results in a quicker time than other fertilizers out there. 

You can purchase their lawn starters to grow your plants more effectively and efficiently. You will want to purchase their care fertilizer to maintain its beautiful color and overall health over time. No matter what you purchase, you will be reaping more returns for the price you pay for. 


How to Find a Good Fertilizer That Will Not Destroy Your Lawn – A Buyer’s Guide 

Purchasing your fertilizer for new grass will determine your lawn’s success. If you make the right decision, you will reap the benefit of your good decision. However, purchasing the wrong fertilizer will eventually damage your lawn. 

The numerous options on the Internet become less intimidating when you find out the kind of fertilizer you want. Thus, we provided you a few factors to consider ensuring that you make the best decision for you and your lawn. 

What Kind of Soil are You Planting?

Before purchasing any fertilizer, you must first determine the state of the soil you want to plant your seeds in. Some soils are more brutal than others. Thus, some fertilizers specialize in ensuring your soil is receptive enough for your grass seeds. You will most likely see a different ratio in these fertilizers than others. 

Fertile soil does not need stronger NPK ratios. Instead, you will want to purchase a more balanced fertilizer to maintain the state of your soil. Purchasing stronger fertilizers might damage your lawn rather than beautifying it. 

Purchase from Recognized Brands

Popular brands usually have more experience than new entrants. More established companies will most likely provide you the fertilizer perfect for your lawn. 

Purchasing from an unrecognized seller might cause you to buy a fertilizer that will not benefit your lawn. You might end up purchasing a fertilizer that will damage your lawn rather than fixing it. 

If you are a beginner, we recommend checking their company’s website for the comments of their customers about the product. These comments should provide you the necessary information before arriving at a decision. 

Safety First

Try to purchase fertilizers that are safer than others. Most effective fertilizers are considered safe to walk on after application. However, other fertilizers also contain dangerous chemicals potentially dangerous for children and pregnant women. 

If you are part of a household, we recommend purchasing a product that will protect your family. Your children should safely run around the lawn after a few hours of applying your fertilizer. 

How Much are You Willing to Invest

We do not recommend purchasing cheaper fertilizers. These fertilizers might not contain the sufficient nutrients your soil needs. These fertilizers also might contain dangerous substances that might serve as a replacement for organic material. 

On the other hand, you do not need to invest a large sum of money to purchase high-end fertilizers. There are medium-range fertilizers that will provide you the benefits almost like high-end ones. These fertilizers are also organic and natural compared to artificial and synthetic. 

Fertilizers do not have to be too expensive, but it also cannot be too cheap. Understand that creating a beautiful will require a sum of investment to sustain it. Thus, investing in good fertilizers is non-negotiable in your buying decision.  


Conclusion 

We provided you eight (8) of the best fertilizers we believe will benefit new grass. We showed you our recommendation for the best fertilizer and the best brand you can run to when in doubt. We also provided you with a series of factors to consider limiting the number of choices you need to select. 

The biggest takeaway from this review is how much investment you need to maintain your lawn. Buying quality products will most likely be more expensive than cheaper ones. The question must revolve around how to select the best fertilizer among the amazing fertilizers out there. Good luck! 


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

What nutrients are needed when planting new grass?

The nutrients will most likely depend on the kind of soil you plan on planting your seeds in. However, most starter fertilizers contain more amounts of Phosphorus and Nitrogen to contribute to the seed’s overall health. 

How should I fertilize new grass seed?

Purchase starter fertilizers when starting grass in new lawns. You will usually see significant results in 6-8 weeks after sowing. 

Can you put starting fertilizer on existing grass?

Starting fertilizers are only for new lawns. Try to purchase more balanced fertilizers when you already have healthier grass. 

Leave a Comment