Top 8 Best Lawn Aerators | 2020 Reviews (Yard Butler)

Your lawn might become compact and dry out with the influence of changing weather and temperature conditions. Some soils might eventually lose nutrients as less space is available for the right amount of water and let nutrition flow. Lawn aerators are invented to solve this problem by loosening up your lawn’s soil at least once a year.

You can be overwhelmed by the wide variety of choices in lawn aerator products in the market today. Luckily, a ready-made list is already provided to choose the best lawn aerator that will best suit your needs.

Dive in the list below of the lawn aerators we could find for you and grab one now while they are still available. You wouldn’t want to miss out on the best ones, would you?  

Top 8 Best Lawn Aerators Reviewed

  1. Yard Butler Lawn Coring Aerator – Best Overall
  2. Earthwise Corded Electric Tiller/Cultivator – Best Value
  3. Mdikawe Lawn Aerator Shoes – Editor’s Choice
  4. Fiskars 40 to 60-Inch Telescoping Rotary Cultivator
  5. Craftsman Tow Spike Aerator
  6. Plantnomics Lawn Aerator Shoes with Hook-and-Loop Straps
  7. Agri-Fab 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator
  8. Agri-Fab Tow Spiker/Seeder/Spreader

#1. Yard Butler Lawn Coring Aerator – Best Overall

Yard Butler Lawn Coring Aerator

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: manual plug aerator
  • Size (in): 1.75 x 8.75 x 36.5
  • Penetrates at 0.5in wide, 3.5in deep
  • 37in high
  • Weight: 3.72lbs

Yard Butler has been making over fifty different yard and garden tools that are tough, sustainable, innovative, and built for everyone’s needs. Their plug aerator is one of the bestselling products on Amazon. It is also tagged as Amazon’s choice for lawn aerators. 

You’ll love the simplicity of this tool and its effective function of aerating your lawn soil. You can have more control in nourishing your lawn by manually reducing soil compaction and dethatch the soil, letting air, water, and fertilizer go to the roots of your lawn. Your lawn will be reborn with your own hands with the help of this aerator.

It is ergonomically designed to be an extension of your body for more controlled lawn management. It has foot leverage that uses your body weight to effectively dig it deep down the toughest and most compact soil. 

It will be easier to aerate your small to medium-sized lawn with its towering height of 37in. Back strains will be prevented, and fatigue for lowering your body when trying to get more leverage. Its steel construction makes it last to serve you longer than any other tool in your garage.

If you’re looking for a manual lawn aerator that is built to last and proven to be effective in doing its job of airing your lawn, this is for you. 

ProsCons
Proven and tested to be effective for many purchasers
Exhaustion from manual effort
Gives more control and leverage
Incompatible for large lawns
Long enough for convenience
Painful work for hands
Durable and long-lasting
Easier for wet soil
Cheaper option

#2. Earthwise Corded Electric Tiller/Cultivator – Best Value

Earthwise Corded Electric Tiller/Cultivator

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: corded electric
  • 12.5-Amp electric motor
  • Size (in): 53 x 12 x 18
  • Cultivates/Tills/Aerates 16in wide, 8in deep
  • Weight: 12.97lbs

If you want none of the manual labor, this would be a smart choice, as it has a powerful motor that can aerate your lawn faster and with more ease than manual ones. It is more reasonable to use a powered machine to look for maximum convenience and have some extra budget to spare.

This tool can dig wide and deep if you want to have maximum aeration to cultivate or till your lawn. Despite its large body, it is lightweight, maneuverable, and can be handled by anyone, even people with small-framed bodies. Its soft grip makes a comfortable handle that will protect your hands from pain and fatigue. 

It is easy to use and can readily be turned on with a single lever switch once plugged in. You’ll have no trouble in pushing it onward, with its powerful blades and two rear wheels that will make your aeration experience smooth and manageable. 

If you’re looking for a powered machine aerator that will eliminate most of your manual labor, this product will do the job! It will be a great investment for the convenience and power that it offers. 

ProsCons
Powered machine offers less effort
Incompatible for lawns that need minimal aeration and disturbance
Lightweight and maneuverableTakes some time to read the manual for the best experience
Deep soil coverage
Its cord can be a hassle
Comfortable
Expensive choice

#3. Mdikawe Lawn Aerator Shoes – Editor’s Choice

Mdikawe Lawn Aerator Shoes

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: aerator shoes
  • With 26 spikes
  • Size (in): 13.39 x 6.69 x 1.57
  • Weight: 1.5lbs

These sandal aerators are newly released products in the market yet have been receiving raves on Amazon. This 26-spike sandal gets aeration done without complex machinery. It is a cost-effective way to get your soil loose without much effort. You can conveniently strap these on the sole of your boots or shoes and conveniently aerate your lawn to get some air and water flowing in your soil in no time.

It is made of durable plastic material with sturdy spikes to dig in compact soil by merely stepping on the target areas. You can simply make a couple of steps without experiencing any irritation or discomfort as gravity does almost all the work.

It is ergonomically designed to give a universal fit for both men and women. You can adjust its four straps to get a snug fit that would firmly hold into your footwear while you leisurely walk around your lawn while aerating it.

A wrench comes with the purchase of a pair of these shoe aerators for easy installation. The manufacturers also guarantee a full refund if you received a defective product. Their customer service will be ready to assist you and give a reply within 24 hours.

If you’re looking for an affordable aerator that will require minimal effort to get the job done, this would be a great choice. 

ProsCons
Has a full refund guarantee with great customer serviceQuestionable durability of plastic material
Fit for everybody’s use
Has minimal coverage and soil reach
Simple and easy to use
Comes with a wrench
Require less effort
Affordable

#4. Fiskars 40 to 60-Inch Telescoping Rotary Cultivator

Fiskars 40 to 60-Inch Telescoping Rotary Cultivator

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: rotary tines
  • Six aluminum wheels
  • Size (in): 5.1 x 9.9 x 39.4 
  • Length: 40-60in
  • Weight: 2.4lbs

This tool has six aluminum non-rust wheels with tines for effective loosening of the soil, removing weeds and mulch. It can conquer tough soil and stubborn weeds that infiltrate your lawn. It has 40in length that can be adjusted to 60in, so you won’t have to bend or kneel to get a good grip while cultivating the soil on your lawn.

You can adjust the handle and set it to your desired length with a security lock while twisting it to secure the handle. You can conveniently roll this over your lawn for your weeds or aeration. Its multifunctional properties make it unique and worth the price.

The center wheel can be removed to allow cultivation around seedling rows. It will avoid ruining your seedlings or already established plants while still giving maintenance to its surrounding area that needs weed control or aeration.

If you need a multipurpose lawn aerator that can remove your lawn’s weeds while aerating the soil simultaneously, this is worth trying. 

ProsCons
Adjustable to avoid plant or seedling rowsNot detailed and clear with maintenance or use instructions
Has a convenient adjustable handle
Durability is questionable
Multifunctional
Non-rust tines

#5. Craftsman Tow Spike Aerator

Craftsman Tow Spike Aerator

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: tow spike aerator
  • Nine-spikes with steel-frame
  • Size (in): 36.25 x 37 x 14  
  • Working width: 36in
  • Weight: 30.4lbs

If you have a large lawn that needs some wide coverage of aeration in one run, this would be a great choice. It can cover up to 36in of area with its nine galvanized star-shaped steel spikes that can penetrate deep into the soil of your lawn. 

It is made with a ten-gauge durable steel frame that makes up the weight tray and encloses the aerator spikes. The enclosed weight tray can accommodate up to 80lbs for maximum soil penetration. 

All brands of riding mowers and tractors will be compatible with its universal design. This lawn aerator conveniently goes over your target areas, wherever you wish to move your mower or tractor. It reduces manual effort while giving a powerful force for your lawn’s soil to loosen up effectively.

An adjustable hitch can also be modified to set different heights to accommodate your tractor, making it compatible with any of your towing machines. It will give a smooth operation with a simple use of cantilever transport handling, making it accessible for you to control raising and lowering mechanisms.

If you are looking for a powerful lawn aerator covering large lawns, this Craftsman beast can do the job with maximum soil penetration. 

ProsCons
Durable steel spike and frame materialChallenging, takes some time and effort for turns
Powerful weight capacity and function
Impractical for small lawns
Highly adjustable and compatibleRelatively expensive
Wide and deep soil coverageHeavy
Reduced manual labor

#6. Plantnomics Lawn Aerator Shoes with Hook-and-Loop Straps

Plantnomics Lawn Aerator Shoes with Hook-and-Loop Straps

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: aerator shoes
  • Has 26 pre-assembled spikes
  • Size (in): 12.5 x 5.5 x 4.4
  • Depth reach: 2in
  • Weight: 1.9lbs

You can leisurely walk around your lawn and aerate them with spikes that are strapped in a pair of included boots. Pierce tiny holes in your lawn that create enough room for water, nutrients, and air to nourish your lawn. 

The boots that come with these strapped spikes is a one size fits all that has a universal fit with a recommended weight limit of 220lbs. Three adjustable foot straps will give a snug fit. It has a hook-and-loop feature that secures your boot for a stable walk around your lawn while piercing your soil effortlessly.

Your purchase comes with pre-assembled spikes on a pair of boots, a comprehensive user manual, and a wrench tool that you can use to maintain and tighten the spikes. These aerator shoes’ durability is guaranteed as they are made with strong polypropylene plastic and nickel-coated steel that can make this product last longer.

If you are looking for a cheaper option for a lawn aerator, a pair of aerator shoes might be just what you need that can offer convenience and durable materials in doing its job. 

ProsCons
With a comprehensive manual and a wrenchSmall area coverage
Comes with one-size-fits-all boots
Limited depth reach
Cheaper option for a lawn aerator
Less effort needed
Durable

#7. Agri-Fab 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator

Agri-Fab 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: push spike aerator
  • With 7in spikes
  • Size (in): 18 x 12 x 36
  • Working width: 16in
  • Weight: 16.46lbs

You can walk behind this push spike aerator while pushing it with ease to your target areas for soil aeration. It can cover up to 16in wide, which will be perfect for medium-sized lawns. Its five aerating wheels with 7in-spikes attached to them allow deep penetration to the lawn soil.

It can expose your lawn for the better flow of nutrients and water for up to 2.5in-depth. A steel weight tray can accommodate 35lbs weight on top for maximum pressure, further pushing the blades of this tool against your lawn. 

This easy push and go tool will make your job easier because of its sharp rolling blades that can cut through your tough soil. Its durable heavy-gauge steel deck will last you for years to come with the proper care and use.

If you are looking for a durable push aerator that can penetrate effectively, deep into your medium-sized lawn, this is for you. 

ProsCons
In-between tool for manual and powered machine aeratorsHarder turns due to pressure block
Has a wide and deep penetration coverage
Dry soil takes more effort to move
Adjustable pressure for added power
May be dangerous for your feet
Sharp and effective
Durable

#8. Agri-Fab Tow Spiker/Seeder/Spreader

Agri-Fab Tow Spiker/Seeder/Spreader

Check Price on Amazon

 

Specifications:

  • Type: tow spike aerator
  • With eight galvanized steel spikes
  • Size (in): 36 x 42 x 20
  • Working width: 32in
  • Weight: 37.5lbs

Large lawns will need this large and powerful tow spike aerator that covers a wide area for a single run. This type of aerator would need a tower or a large machine that will move it across your lawn for a heavy-duty lawn aeration that can cover up to 17,000sq. ft.

This multifunctional and heavy-duty machine can aerate, seed, and spread simultaneously in one run. It makes your job easier and faster, even for your large lawn. You won’t have to worry about it wearing down quickly as it is made of a rustproof poly hopper material that increases its longevity.

You can put up to 100lbs weight on its hopper to maximize the pressure to penetrate the blades against your soil. This weight makes it easier for the blades to penetrate tough soil and go deeper for maximum soil loosening and aeration. The 10in, flat-free wheels will aid the smooth motion of this lawn aerator across your whole lawn at any terrain condition.

A convenient universal fit hitch is designed to fit all machine towers to help this tool move powerfully to your target areas. A steel lift handle is also easily accessible to give you the convenience of adjusting your aerator’s height to fit your needs.

If you’re looking for a powerful lawn aerator that can cover large lawns fast and smoothly, then this lawn aerator would be a great investment for 

ProsCons
High weight capacity for the tray to maximize pressure
Requires a powerful towing machine
Multifunctional aerator, seeder, and spreader
High maintenance
Rustproof, durable materialChallenging turns
Deep soil penetrationHeavyweight
Large area coverage
Expensive
Adjustable height

Top Pick – Best Lawn Aerator

The Yard Butler Lawn Coring Aerator made it to the top of the list for the best lawn aerators in the market today. It is one of the bestsellers on Amazon for the lawn aerator category. It is a manual plug type that requires more effort for you, yet it certainly does the job with its budget-friendly price.

Your lawn can be nourished through plugging, which can be more controlled for targeting specific areas on your lawn. This controlled mechanism gives you the power to avoid spot areas like your flowerbeds or seedlings, for example.

Despite its manual nature, the manufacturers have designed it to still be convenient through its size and well-engineered parts. Other mechanically powered options can do the same with a little more convenience for a larger cost, but if you have a small lawn or garden to maintain, this lawn aerator is a more practical buy. It simply functions well as it is durable, having no complex parts that may cause the product to fail.


Buyer’s Guide: Noteworthy Features for Selecting Your Lawn Aerator

Type

Plug

For lawns that are more compact and tough to penetrate, this type of lawn aerator will be most effective. It can penetrate your tough and hardened lawn while removing chunks of soil. Lawns that accumulate water that pools on certain spots because of clumped or compact soil are good candidates for plug aerators. 

Chunks of soil removed can be piled away by a rake or a mower or just be left in place to decompose. Large holes made by plug aerators will allow the roots to be exposed and your soil to finally get the nutrients they need. Eventually, your lawn can soften down as the soil and plants become nourished. 

Spike

Lawns with looser soil will benefit from spike aerators as it moves soil out of the way to make them looser, creating a denser soil structure. Deeper parts of your lawn can be exposed and nourished. It increases root exposure and allows more nutrients to penetrate with more given space. This type is best used for cultivation, giving more space for seeds to settle, preventing it from running off your lawn’s soil surface. 

Aerator Shoes

This type of aerator uses spikes attached to a sandal, which you can strap around your shoes or boots. It uses your body weight to give pressure in digging the spikes into the soil. These are becoming more popular as it would require less effort with the help of gravity. You can leisurely walk around your lawn and step on the soil areas that you want to treat. 

Aeration Method

Push

This method and type of aeration will benefit small to medium-sized lawns that have compact soil. This method would prevent obstacles such as plants or planted seedlings that you may not want to disturb, allowing you to effectively treat target areas. Push type of aerators are less common and would usually require manual labor to push the tines into firm soil. However, it is more effective than spike types if you want to treat hardened soil. 

Hand-held

This kind of method comes with plug or spike type aerators. It is best used for small to medium-sized lawns as it also requires more effort to repeatedly dig into the soil. A dual handgrip will allow you to have good leverage to prevent some strain on your back. A strong foot platform will help you to dig the tines or spikes into the soil repeatedly until your lawn is completely aerated. 

Tow-behind

Larger lawns are treated with large aerators covering more ground within a single run for a more efficient and effective job. A mower or a towing machine is attached to these large aerators to propel them forward as their rotary spikes dig into the soil and make them loose. Trays are designed above their spikes to accommodate some extra weight, such as bricks, to pressure it to dig deep into the soil. 

Working Width

This feature will give you an idea of how wide an aerator can cover in one run. Larger lawns would be aerated more efficiently with aerators that have larger working widths. However, if you maintain a small area, it would be more practical to buy smaller aerators with a smaller working width, which is easier to maneuver, cheaper, and avoid spot areas. 

Weight

Lightweight aerators will allow you to maneuver them with ease. They will reduce body strains and fatigue in the long run. Lighter tools are generally easier to store and maintain as well. However, you can expect large aerators for bigger lawns to be heavier for a more heavy-duty performance that would require some other machine aid to move effectively. 

Size

The size of aerators gives you an idea if you can store them in your garage effectively. You wouldn’t buy an aerator that wouldn’t fit in your storage area.

The length of an aerator, particularly its handle, will give more convenience if it matches your height to fit you well. The right size or length for your aerator would impact your comfort in using the tool. 

Material

Aerator spikes and tines are effectively made with sharp galvanized steel to dig into the soil powerfully. Their frames and handles are also made more effective and durable with steel frames. This steel make-up makes aerators heavier but more dependable. However, for aerator shoes, the spikes are usually attached to plastic material that should be durable yet light enough to dig in and out of the soil easily. 

Brand

Buyers usually prefer reputable, well-known brands that manufacture lawn equipment because they trust in their established name. They rose to fame because of their superior materials and advanced engineering techniques that they have learned throughout the years, making their products unique with special features that make it more convenient for the users. 

However, branded products may be more costly because of their established platform and high-quality materials. Other manufacturers are also rising, offering cheaper yet great performing options that you may want to consider if you are meticulous enough to know their products’ features to ensure that you get what you pay for.

Cost

All the features mentioned above affect the cost of a lawn aerator. You should ensure that you know the best features to look for to maximize the price that you pay when purchasing your lawn aerator. You may look for low budget aerators yet give a great performance, minus special features that give more convenience. Some tools have a simple construction but would function well and do the job. However, some products also give unreasonable prices when you can find cheaper alternatives that exceed your expectations. That’s why it’s important to know the features to consider so you can be satisfied with your purchase.


Conclusion

Aerating your lawn is important to maintain its good spacing for water and nutrients to seep evenly within its soil. However, it can be hard work, so it’s best to work with the best lawn aerators offered in the market today to help you treat your lawn effectively.

The Yard Butler Lawn Coring Aerator topped the list as the best lawn aerator due to its ability to effectively do its job as many verified purchasers have praised this tool on Amazon. It has balanced features that most buyers are looking for, making it one of Amazon’s bestsellers.

It is important to consider the right features when selecting a lawn aerator for you. Many factors should be considered, from the size or type of soil your lawn has. Various lawns will have different compatibility for lawn aerators. 

No matter how well-designed a tool is, it wouldn’t work well if it is not used the way it’s intended to. You can read the buyer’s guide for a background and some knowledge of what type of lawn aerator you should buy that would best fit you and your lawn’s needs to get satisfaction from your purchased product.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

How frequently should I aerate my lawn?

Aerating should be done once a year for healthy lawns. Lawns with compact soil are advised to aerate their lawn twice a year to loosen it up for water and nutrients to seep-in effectively. If you notice that pools of water are starting to accumulate on your lawn even with light watering, it is probably time to aerate it now as the soil may be too compact to let water seep deep into the roots of your plants.

When is the best time to aerate my lawn?

The best time is in the early summer or fall to give thick and denser grass. Aerating your lawn during the spring exposes your plants’ roots to moisture, allowing fungal infections or diseases to penetrate your plants. Aerating during the spring also helps the growth of weeds.

What preparations should I do to my lawn before aeration?

Your lawn should be mowed at the height of 1.5-2in. Clippings and mowed grass should be raked and put aside to get the maximum blade or tine to soil contact, making it easier for you and your tool. Watering your soil three days before aeration also helps your soil soften a little to help your lawn aerator penetrate your lawn’s soil.

Leave a Comment